In this age of identity theft, who posts their private data online? Certainly not me. I’ve already had my share of death threats from exposing 3rd World spammers pretending to be accountants from Massachusetts. (Right, zeny888?) So why would a social network run by Harvard grads not understand such a simple concept as the right to privacy. Using your real name online is a serious mistake everyone should avoid unless you are already in the news. Even then, you need a fake name to interact socially without overzealous fans stalking your every online move. You don’t want your Facebook experience to end up on CNN. So how do you avoid breaking the Facebook rule against ”providing any false personal information in your profile”. In short, you can’t, because Facebook is run by morons.
I have numerous online friends. Not one of them uses the name on their drivers license. Some are stage names, nick names, or even a shortened form of their real name, like “Tim” instead of “Timothy”. In my own case, I use the name “Turnip” as this is the name my friends know me by. Over one year ago I created a Facebook page and then completely forgot about it. Note that I can’t actually view my page linked above, but more on that later. About 6 months after creating the first page, I added a page for my blog turnipofpower.com. A few friends joined and that was that. I didn’t actually use Facebook, but readers requested I “friend” them, so I did. Now, here is where things get stupid.
Facebook allows advertisers to run ads at a reasonable rate. Being an internet marketer, I decided to run some ads on Facebook and registered my credit card to pay for the advertising. An intern approved my ads, and they began to run. Suddenly my account was cancelled. Not my ads, but my Facebook account itself. The dreaded “Your account has been disabled by an administrator. If you have any questions or concerns, you can visit our FAQ page here” message. So I followed the link and got a reply.
Someone named “Gaston” replied. Gaston had a complicated explanation and solution for me, which I followed to the letter. Here is his reasoning “Per our Terms of Use, Facebook profiles must represent an individual. Users aren’t permitted to maintain an account under an organization’s name, or use personal accounts to advertise or promote themselves professionally. We apologize for the inconvenience, but you will no longer be able to use this account.”
OK, so Gaston set me up with a new account. I resubmit all my ads, re-register my credit cards, and I think I’m up and running. I might even get to review Facebook as a legitimate ad network. Nope, wasn’t to be. 3 days later my account is frozen again. Who would be so rude? My friend “Gaston again”.
Unfortunately, your new account under your email address was disabled as you used a fake name. Please provide me with your real name and I will re-enable your account for you. If Turnip Smith is your real name, please attach an image of your driver’s license in a response to this email.”
So, I need to send some idiot a copy of my driver’s license. Someone named “Gaston”, with no last name, and probably a fake name, come to think about it. I got news for people, if you ever send your drivers license or other personal info through an email, you are an idiot. Email gets hacked, forwarded, and printed. The printed copy is then left on a desk, thrown out in the trash for any dumpster diver to see, or simply copied by the cleaning crew at night. Sorry Gaston, but the very fact you didn’t sign your email with your real name, address, and drivers license told me all I needed to know: Your company is run by idiots.
Now why hasn’t Facebook asked all 500 million of its other members using “fake” names for a copy of their driver’s license? That answer is easy. I committed the horrible crime of using a $25 coupon code to launch my advertising campaign. Yep, Gaston’s job is to ban anyone using Facebook coupon codes based upon any technicality he can. Even accounts he personally reinstated.
Facebook needs to wake up. My credit card is good. I spend a lot of money per year running ads. My crime? I’m not using my real name on Facebook because it would cost me my day job, endanger my family, and embarrass companies I perform consulting services for. For over a year my account was good, but the second I enter a coupon online, I get banned, twice. This is not the way to run an ad network. Spammers creating fake accounts by the ten’s of thousands to play Mobwars is fine, but using the name I’m known by online isn’t.
So now “Gaston” reverted my new account to the old account, neither of which I can access. I get a daily dose of viagra spam from Facebook and I can’t turn it off. Why? It says “Want to control which emails you receive from Facebook? Go to:http://www.facebook.com/editaccount.php“. All of which brings me back to the original “Your account has been frozen”. Guess what Facebook idiots, you are now in violation of the CAN-SPAM Act of 2003 which requires “A visible and operable unsubscribe mechanism is present in all emails.” I cannot access my account, the mechanism is inoperable, I can’t stop your spam.
Gaston will be hearing more about this, I can assure you.
Plurk This Post
Buzz This Post
Delicious
Digg This Post
Ping This Post
Reddit This Post
Stumble This Post

It had to be said. Nice job Mr. Turnip Smith.
Using your real name on these kind of services is just asking for trouble, and I never understood why Facebook required it. I guess it’s because they want the service to serve the “find your classmate or old friends” purpose?
Personally I think they’re stupid for limiting themselves like that; so I gotta give you an affirmative to the question in the title.
The irony of this facebook employee only being known as “Gaston” is hilarious. Good luck getting that email spam taken care of. Terrible oversight on their part.
Do you know they filter certain prefixes in emails? I tried a dozen times originally to sign up with my legitimate email accounts, which I normally set up as email@domain.com as opposed to nickname@domain.com.
For some reason, email@ triggers something and they say “you must use a legitimate email account” or some horseshit. I eventually had to make an additional email account calling it whatever@domain.com just to get through their damn registration system.
I guess they thought email@ was some kind of throw away email? Annoying.
Well — next thing you know, they’ll want thumbprints, dental records and full body cavity searches before you can use their service the way it was intended.
This is so ridiculous. I opened a Facebook account a few months back, looked around for about 20 minutes and have never been back. I am not planning to go back neither. Facebook has nothing to offer that I would be interested in.
I hope you sort this Gaston out.
He’s just a pawn in the Online Sales Operations. I have no animosity towards him. But he is cancelling accounts to avoid paying out on legitimate coupons. Every company has a hidden terms of service policy that states “we reserve the right to refuse service to any person for any reason”. When you discover only people of a certain race are refused, or only people who dare enter a coupon are refused, then it becomes a larger issue. Exactly how “Gaston” psychicly determines what my real name is or isn’t is beyond me.
I hope you check this out and let me know what you think :
http://bmw230.blogspot.com/search/label/Face%20Book
Beamer
I tried to follow your link, but it says “not found”. This link worked: http://bmw230.blogspot.com/2008/06/i-used-to-belong-to-facebook.html good video on why not to use facebook.
Facebook has become my address book, because most of my friends change their email addresses more than I do. If I could get a current email address for everyone on my friends list, I’d consider deleting my account – but most of these people rarely use email as it is, let alone remember to tell everyone who might have the old address.
Living on the other side of the world from virtually everyone I know means it is nice to be able to stay in touch. And I do like seeing the photos from my friends and family. It certainly helps with the “friend of a friend” people whose names I can’t remember.
But I rarely use Facebook except for the occasional message. Once back in the UK I could just phone people – or meet up! Facebook has replaced a lot of the conversations I might have with people face to face, which I’m not too thrilled about.
As I already use my real name online (but not my full name), deleting my Facebook account wouldn’t make much sense. Maybe I’ll reconsider once I’m back in the UK.
lol. this story makes me frankly glad that I never bothered with facebook in the first place
Personally, I’d rather advertisers stay out of facebook. I use it to connect with people I’m apart from and I’d prefer not to be distracted by advertisements for crap that I don’t even really care for. Everytime I’ve clicked on an ad, I’ve been disappointed by some bullshit someone is trying to sell me.
In a way I guess I’m agreeing with you that Facebook is run by morons because they allow bullshit to be advertised to me but won’t allow you to because you refuse to provide your real name.
All I know is, I want them to stop advertising to me. Period.
Blogger can be so freaking weird at times. I don’t know how that link came about, because I was sure what I had copied was the one you showed. Teach me.
What really bothered me was when I left Facebook, I was told no problem, just come back to us any time you want and ALL your info will be here waiting for you. WTF?
Just think of all the data that they have stored on all the people that have left there? It doesn’t make any sense to me. I’m sure they could put better use to the Storage space my little bit of info is using up.
Beamer
Fragile, if you want Facebook to keep running, ads are probably a vital part of that. Did you see the thumbs up / thumbs down icons beneath the ads? Those allow you to rate the ads you see.
And I’ve rated all of them except for the charity ones (because I didn’t want to be *that* person) with a thumbs down. That doesn’t mean I see any less ads.
You know what I hate about Facebook? I’ve run into about 200 people that I went to high school with back in the 80′s, and I’ve come to the realization that out of them all, I’m the biggest loser of the bunch. Well, there was that one guy that got shot by the cops breaking and entering, so I guess I should say “biggest loser of those still living”.
Can you imagine Dee Anderson answering that infamous question with “I wanna blog, blog!”
I know this is a short comment for me, but my mother said its too late to be on the computer.
There is a problem when we can’t keep our privacy and are forced into giving our real name out. What we need is some type of credit card that allows you to use a alias name. Not sure if that would work or create more problems.
Facebook is weird, that is for sure.
I’ve never really had an interest in Facebook myself. Any friends I cared to keep up with through the years I have, and family as well.